When I first heard this story I did not believe it. A ten-year-old girl with Stage II ductal breast cancer?  It just did not make any sense!

First of all you need to have breasts to have breast cancer. This meant she either had a tumor of her breast bud or premature puberty, which in and of itself suggests that she had an unusual level of hormones.

It was only after the story had been widely reported that it became clear that little girl had a secretory cancer, which is NOT the kind of breast cancer that adult women get.

When these secretory cancers were first described in the medical literature in 1966, they were referred to as “juvenile breast cancer” because the only known patients were children or very young women. These cancers are incredibly rare, making up less than .15% of breast cancers, and they are typically associated with an excellent prognosis.

It is sad when any child gets cancer, and I’m sure it’s been very hard on this young girl and her family. We should not, however, get carried away.  This is a very rare tumor and the fact that it occurred in a 10-year-old girl does not mean that we need to start screening children or young women for breast cancer. It is important that young girls see their breasts as wonderful, nurturing parts of their bodies. The last thing we want to do is have them think that their breasts are body parts that are going to turn on them at a moment’s notice.

Relax folks—rare diseases are rare! Currently, the best-known way to prevent breast cancer is physical exercise, particularly around puberty and the teen-age years. This means what we really should be worrying about is obesity in children, and lack of physical activity. We need to turn our attention to all the girls who no longer have PE in school and who never get any exercise at all! Let’s see some news stories about that!

Share →

3 Responses to A 10-Year-Old Girl With Breast Cancer?

  1. Carmen Dager says:

    I have a Dx. DCIS and ER/PR positive.

    Fallow on my radiation I need to take the

    Tamoxifen, but the a side effect is clot in

    the lung and my QDIMER is hight. How can I

    do? Please answer me at : ccdager@yahoo.com

  2. Leslie says:

    Dr. Love,

    Why are 25 year old girls getting breast cancer? My daughter has a friend with breast cancer and she has been physically active all her lives. Not obese either. Also tested for the BRCA gene and results were negative.

    My daughter is worried about getting breast cancer. I told her this is rare and we can’t live life worrying. :-)

    Thank you for all your hard work to find a cure for breast cancer!!!

  3. Tammy says:

    How did this 10 year old find the breast cancer? I have a ten year old daughter who fits this profile. She has developed large breast already.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>